About Emmy Squared Midtown West
Emmy Squared started in Clinton Hill, Brooklyn in 2014 (from Emily and Matt Hyland) and built its name on Detroit-style pizza after a trip to Detroit — the crispy cheese edge, airy dough, and bold red sauce, topped with chef-driven combinations. The Midtown West outpost brings that one-of-a-kind fare to the neighborhood, paired with a full bar and specialty cocktails in a modern, low-key room.
The Happy Hour in Detail
The “Tiers of Cheers” happy hour runs Monday through Thursday, 4 to 6pm: $5 select beer plus discounted wine, select cocktails, and happy-hour bites. It’s a relaxed, midweek window — and as reviewers note, an earlier weekday seating is also the quieter way to enjoy a dining room that gets loud and lively at peak. Confirm the current full lineup when you go.
What to Order
The Detroit-style square pies are the headline — the SIXER for one or two, the TENNER for a group — with toppings ranging from classic pepperoni-and-honey to truffle-mushroom and pesto-Calabrian-chili. Don’t sleep on the Le Big Matt, a double-stack burger named one of NYC’s best by Gothamist and The Infatuation, served on a pretzel bun with waffle fries. Round it out with mozzarella sticks, garlic breadsticks, or wings.
The Space & Vibe
Casual, modern, and pizza-forward, with a lively, informal energy that works for a relaxed dinner, a casual date, or a pre-show bite. The dining room runs loud at peak, so an earlier or midweek visit is the move if you want it calmer. Vegan cheese and gluten-free crust are available on the smaller pies, and there are options for larger-group ordering and events.
The Midtown Angle
In Midtown West, near the Theater District and the western edge of the neighborhood, Emmy Squared is an easy, crowd-pleasing pre- or post-show option — a square pie and a $5 beer that beats most of what’s around it. It’s part of a growing NYC roster, so it’s a known quantity wherever you find it.
Who It’s For
| Best for | Why |
|---|---|
| An early dinner | a relaxed table on the Upper West Side |
| Happy-hour bite | the deal: $5 select beer |
| Groups | works for a table of friends on the Upper West Side |
| A quick one | in and out before a show or a shift |