Hamburger America: George Motz’s Classic Burger Counter in SoHo
Hamburger America, at 51 MacDougal Street (entrance on West Houston), is the luncheonette-style burger counter from George Motz — the “Burger Scholar” of First We Feast and Travel Channel fame, and author of the book the place is named after. Opened in late 2023, it’s a tiny diner of around a dozen stools, built as a love letter to classic regional American burgers and run like a time capsule without the kitsch.
There’s no happy hour here, but there doesn’t need to be — the whole menu is a deal, and a cold Miller High Life is six bucks.
What to Expect
A counter, some stools, and serious burgers:
- A burger is $7.25 — fried onions, gooey American cheese (fries are an extra $4.25)
- A Miller High Life is $6; a hot ham or tuna sandwich is $7
- Counter seating — watch the patties get smashed on the griddle
- Cash and cards; expect a wait at peak times for such a small room
The Food
Motz’s mission is to recreate what hamburgers used to taste like, using historically accurate ingredients and methods. The result is consistently called some of the best smashburgers in the city — the classic and the onion burger especially — alongside regional American burgers, hot ham and tuna sandwiches, fresh-squeezed lemonade, and chocolate milk.
The Room
An authentic, ~11–15-stool diner with an open kitchen and a 1960s feel — “a step back in time,” as the regulars put it. Opening day famously drew Chris Rock, Sean Evans, Christy Turlington and Michael Bloomberg, but day to day it’s a friendly counter where the staff run the show.
Who Hamburger America Is For
| Occasion | Why It Works |
|---|---|
| A cheap great meal | A $7.25 burger and a $6 beer in SoHo |
| A solo counter seat | Pull up a stool and watch the griddle |
| A burger pilgrimage | George Motz’s love letter to the American burger |
| A quick beer and bite | In and out for under twenty bucks |