New York City / Buffalo Bills
Bills Bars
in NYC
Two bars claim the Bills in Manhattan. Only one of them is the chapter headquarters.
Bills Mafia in NYC: Continental in FiDi, Penn 6 at Herald Square
- 6 verified rooms
- packages from $50
- beer buckets from $20
- season opens 9 Sept
The short version
- The official barContinental Sports Lounge – “Official Buffalo Bills Backers BAR in FiDi NYC,” 70+ screens and a video wall.
- Chapter HQPennsylvania 6 – $50 unlimited beer and wings, $70 with liquor. Reservation required.
- Biggest appetiteThe Rutherford – $64.95 unlimited wings and beer, Sundays, Mondays and Thursdays.
- CheapestThe Winslow – $20 five-beer buckets, $6 drafts, open till 4am.
- The catchPenn 6 charges $20 a head to cancel inside 48 hours, and The Rutherford publishes no street number.
The Bills bars NYC actually fills on a Sunday are Continental Sports Lounge at 82 Beaver St, the official Buffalo Bills Backers bar in FiDi, and Pennsylvania 6 at 132 W 31st, where the NYC Bills Backers chapter actually meets and where $50 buys unlimited beer and wings. Add The Rutherford near Penn Station for $64.95 all-you-can-eat wings and beer, and The Winslow on East 14th if you would rather spend $20 on a bucket. New York has more Bills infrastructure than any out-of-market fanbase except Cleveland’s, and unusually for this city, most of it publishes real prices.
At a glance
Two backers rooms, two value plays, and two fallbacks. Tap a number on the map to place it.
| Bar | The deal | Days | Window | $ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Continental Sports Lounge | Weekday HH; Sunday Funday 7pm–close | Mon–Thu | 11am–11pm | $$$ |
| Pennsylvania 6 | $50 unlimited beer + wings; $70 full package | Game days | From 30 min pre-kick | $$$ |
| The Rutherford | $64.95 unlimited wings + beer | Sun/Mon/Thu | Game nights | $$$ |
| The Winslow | $20 bucket (5), $6 drafts, $7 wines | Daily | 4–7pm / 12–4pm wknd | $$$ |
| Stout — Bryant Park | NFL RedZone every Sunday; 29 TVs | Sun | All day | $$$ |
| Mustang Harry’s | $6.50 Bud Light, $7.50 craft lager | Daily | 2–5pm | $$$ |
Map: where these 6 spots are
Split between downtown and the Penn Station cluster — Continental is the FiDi option, everything else is within a few blocks of 33rd and 8th.
Pins are numbered to match the table above – tap any pin for the deal and directions.
The Bills bars
Four rooms, four different arguments. One is the official FiDi backers bar, one is the chapter’s literal headquarters, one sells unlimited wings and beer for a flat fee, and one is just cheap and open late. Every claim below is quoted from the venue’s own site or the chapter’s.
Continental Sports Lounge On now
Start here. Continental’s own About page calls it the “Official Buffalo Bills Backers BAR in FiDi NYC,” and it is the only bar downtown with the hardware to back that up — seventy-plus screens and a video wall that goes to the Bills on Sunday. The verdict: if you work below Canal or live anywhere near the water, this is your bar and the argument is over. The local move: three blocks from the 2/3 at Wall St, and it stays busy on weekends when the rest of FiDi is a ghost town. The honest caveat: they advertise game-day bundles but do not publish the price, so ask at the bar rather than budgeting off a number you read somewhere else.
continentalbarnyc.com · See our FiDi happy hour guide
Pennsylvania 6
This is where the New York City Buffalo Bills Backers actually meet — confirmed by the chapter’s own site and by buffalobills.com, which calls it “the home of the NYC Bills Backers.” The packages are the most transparent pricing on this page: $50 for unlimited Bud Light, Budweiser, Labatt Blue and Labatt Light plus wings, or $70 to add house mixed drinks, house wine and Happy Dad seltzers. Packages run from 30 minutes before kickoff to the end of the fourth quarter. The honest caveat, and it is a real one: the packages need a reservation, and cancelling inside 48 hours costs $20 a head. Walk-ins on a big Sunday are a gamble.
nycbbb.com · See our bars near Madison Square Garden
The Rutherford
Their own Bills page is unambiguous: “When the Buffalo Bills hit the field, this is where the Bills Mafia gathers in Midtown Manhattan.” The deal is $64.95 per person for unlimited wings and beer — whole party, Buffalo or plain, with Michelob Ultra, Bud Light, Labatt Blue, Heineken Light, Stella and Truly on the list. That is either the best value or the worst on this page depending entirely on how you drink. The honest caveat, twice over: the venue publishes no street number anywhere on its own site — only the corner of 33rd and 8th — and its homepage says Bills Sundays while the Bills page says Sunday, Monday and Thursday. Call before you commit a group.
therutherfordnyc.com · See our bars near Madison Square Garden
The Winslow On now
The cheapest way to watch the Bills in Manhattan, and the only one on this page with a published happy hour worth the name: $20 for a five-beer bucket of Tecate or Miller High Life, $6 select drafts, $7 Aperol spritz, $7 wines. Weekdays 4–7pm, running to 8pm Tuesday through Thursday, and noon–4pm at weekends. They describe themselves as “a sports bar that is here for you, the Bills fan” — enthusiast language, not a chapter affiliation, and we would rather draw that line than blur it. Worth it: open to 4am Thursday through Saturday, so the night does not end when the game does.
thewinslownyc.com · See our East Village happy hours
If your bar is packed
Bills Sundays fill rooms, and Penn 6 needs a reservation. These two are the reliable fallbacks — see also the full NFL bars in NYC guide and our best sports bars roundup.
Stout — Bryant Park
The answer when your bar is at capacity or the game is a 4:25 you did not plan for. Stout lists this room for “Seattle Seahawks, Ohio State, James Madison and the University of Washington, plus NFL RedZone” — and RedZone is the point. Twenty-nine TVs and a 10-foot projector, the only one of the four Stouts that publishes a screen count. The local move: live DJ 1–6:30pm every football Sunday, so the room stays up after the early window ends. Not a Bills room, but it will have the Bills game on a screen.
stoutnyc.com · See our best sports bars in NYC
Mustang Harry’s On now
Two blocks from Penn, which makes it the obvious meeting point if half your group is coming in on a train. Their own FAQ promises “full ‘Game Sound’ throughout our two-floor space” for big events, and the happy hour is real and published: $6.50 Bud Light, $7.50 house craft lager, $12 shot of the day, 2–5pm and again midnight to 2am. The honest caveat: the bar’s own priority list is Knicks, Rangers, UFC and Ravens, so a Garden night will outrank your football game for the good screens.
mustangharrys.com · See our Chelsea happy hours
Watching the Bills in NYC: FAQ
Where is the official Buffalo Bills bar in NYC?
There are two, and they are different things. Continental Sports Lounge at 82 Beaver Street in FiDi calls itself the “Official Buffalo Bills Backers BAR in FiDi NYC” on its own website, with 70+ screens and a video wall. Pennsylvania 6 at 132 W 31st Street is the home bar of the New York City Buffalo Bills Backers chapter, confirmed by both the chapter’s own site and buffalobills.com. Continental is the better room; Penn 6 is where the organised chapter actually meets.
How much does a Bills watch party cost in NYC?
Pennsylvania 6 runs $50 per person for unlimited Bud Light, Budweiser, Labatt Blue and Labatt Light plus wings, or $70 to add house mixed drinks, house wine and Happy Dad seltzers, running from 30 minutes before kickoff to the end of the fourth quarter. The Rutherford near Penn Station charges $64.95 per person for unlimited wings and beer. Both are per person and apply to the whole party.
Do I need a reservation to watch the Bills in NYC?
For the packages, yes. Pennsylvania 6 requires a booking for its $50 and $70 packages and charges $20 per person if you cancel inside 48 hours. Continental and The Winslow take walk-ins. On a primetime Bills game, get to any of them at least 45 minutes before kickoff.
Where can I watch the Bills cheaply in NYC?
The Winslow at 243 E 14th Street. Happy hour is 4-7pm on weekdays, running to 8pm Tuesday through Thursday and noon to 4pm at weekends: $20 for a five-beer bucket of Tecate or Miller High Life, $6 select drafts, $7 Aperol spritz and $7 wines. It is open until 4am Thursday through Saturday.
Which NYC bars show every Bills game?
Continental Sports Lounge shows Bills games on its video wall and has enough screens that every other game still gets one. Pennsylvania 6 and The Rutherford run dedicated Bills game days – The Rutherford lists Sundays, Mondays and Thursday nights. If all three are full, Stout Bryant Park carries NFL RedZone every Sunday on 29 TVs and a 10-foot projector.
Last updated: September 2026. Deals and hours change – confirm with the venue before you go. Spot something out of date? Let us know.
