Lilly's Cocktail & Wine: $10 Cocktails and a $10 Flatbread on West 72nd
Lilly’s Cocktail & Wine runs happy hour Monday to Thursday 4–7pm and Friday 2–5pm at 50 West 72nd Street on the Upper West Side: $10 cocktails, $9 house wine, $5 drafts and cans, $10 plates and $8 desserts.
The verdict: a good deal if you order right. The regular cocktail list runs $17–19 and wine by the glass starts at $18, so a $10 cocktail or a $9 house pour nearly halves the round. Be choosier with the food. The $10 Margherita flatbread is $19 on the main menu and the pretzel is $12, but the Castelvetrano olives are $10 at any hour, and the happy hour wings are four for $10 against eight for $18 later — you pay more per wing for the discount. The caveat: the five $10 cocktails are their own short list, not the seasonal menu, and there’s nothing on weekends.
The Happy Hour
The window is Monday–Thursday 4–7pm and Friday 2–5pm. Cocktails are $10 — Bombay Bramble, Pumpkintini, Blackberry Smash, Sassy Paloma (jalapeño-infused tequila, grapefruit) and Fallin’ for You (pumpkin-spice vanilla vodka, apple, sage). House wine is $9 a glass in red, white, rosé or sparkling. Beers are $5: house Pilsner and IPA on draft, Two Roads IPA and UFO White in cans, and Montauk IPA and Founders Golden non-alcoholic cans. Plates are $10: loaded hummus, pretzel with three dips, Margherita flatbread, olives, Manchego with prosciutto, four Thai chili wings, white mussels, and Lilly’s nachos. Apple crisp cheesecake, crème brûlée and chocolate lava cake are $8.
The Bar
Lilly’s comes from the owners of Lilly’s Craft and Kitchen in Hell’s Kitchen, and it sells itself as wines by the glass and tapas-style Italian bites. The full menu runs from a $28 cheese and charcuterie board through flatbreads, wraps and $20 lollipop lamb chops. Weekend brunch starts at 11am, with bottomless cocktails offered at an unposted price. The B/C and 1/2/3 at 72nd Street are steps away. More nearby in our Upper West Side happy hour guide and best wine bars in NYC.
Who Lilly’s Is For
| Occasion | Why It Works |
|---|---|
| A cheap dinner after work | $10 Margherita flatbread, $19 off the clock, Mon–Thu 4–7pm |
| An early Friday | Happy hour runs 2–5pm, from the moment it opens |
| Mixed company | $9 house wine and $5 non-alcoholic beers on the same menu |