A happy hour sign on the door doesn't mean a cheap pint, and in this city it usually isn't one. These are the bars whose deal skips the stout, checked against their own menus on 1 November 2026, plus two corrections we owe you.
Most NYC happy hours leave the Guinness at full price. At Whiskey Tavern, Harlem Tavern, The Stag's Head and Tryon Public House, the stout costs the same at 5pm as at midnight ($9 at three of them), and Tír na nÓg, still quoted for a happy hour, has none on its menu. Every price below comes from the bar's own menu, re-checked on 1 November 2026.
| Bar |
The happy hour |
What the Guinness costs during it |
| Whiskey Tavern, Baxter St |
Mon–Fri 3–7pm: $8 wells, $8 wine, $5 Miller High Life, $10 shot and a beer, $20 Miller Lite pitcher |
$9 a pint, $36 a pitcher. Full price. |
| Harlem Tavern, Frederick Douglass Blvd |
Weekdays 4–7pm: "$6 select beer drafts", none of them named |
$9 on the drink menu. Treat it as $9. |
| The Stag's Head, E 51st St |
Mon–Fri 11am–7pm: $6–7 for four named drinks (two lagers, an IPA and a cider), plus $9 wine and $8 wells |
Not on the list. No stout among them. |
| Tryon Public House, Inwood |
Mon–Fri 3–7pm, contents unpublished |
$9 for 16oz on the drink menu. Assume $9. |
| Tír na nÓg, W 31st St |
None on the fall/winter 2026 menu. The posted deal is a $12 weekday lunch. |
$10 for 20oz, all day |
Two of our own. Our FAQ said Tír na nÓg runs a happy hour that skips the stout. It doesn't run a happy hour at all now, so the stout is $10 whenever you go. We also wrote that 11th Street Bar has no website and no published happy hour. Both wrong. It posts the Jack Smead Happy Hour: $2 off all beer, Monday to Friday, 2 to 7pm. Its 20oz Guinness is listed at $10, so $8 in the window. That makes it one of the best-value pours on this page, and it belongs in the cheapest pints.
How to read a happy hour sign. "All draft" or "$X off all beer" covers the stout. That's why Tara Mór ($8 all draft, weekdays 4–6:30pm) is in the cheap section. "Select drafts", "house drafts" or a list of named lagers almost never does. The Wolfhound in Astoria sits in between: "$6 draught beer" weekdays until 7, with no exclusions printed and Guinness never named. Before you order, ask "is the Guinness in it?" It costs you nothing and saves a $9 surprise.
More pints with real prices in the best Irish bars in NYC.