Old Mates Pub: Meat Pies, Coopers and Trivia at an Australian Pub Near the Seaport
Old Mates Pub doesn’t run a happy hour — not one it posts, anyway. The Australian pub at 170 John Street, near the South Street Seaport, lists full prices only: $9 for the house Old Mates Lager, $12 for a Coopers, $15 for a house-baked beef pie and $15 for a cocktail. It opens at noon every day and closes at 1am Monday to Thursday, 2am on Fridays and Saturdays, and 11pm on Sundays.
The verdict: come for the pie and the pint, not a deal. A $15 pie of Westholme wagyu brisket and onion with a $9 house lager is a $24 dinner that’s actually Australian — chips with chicken salt, Kilpatrick oysters, a parma you can order Queenslander-style with pineapple. The honest caveat: nothing here gets cheaper at 5pm, and a $29 chicken parma with a $15 cocktail is a $44 night before tax and tip.
What to Expect
Beer. Ten taps: the house Old Mates Lager, Old Mates Gold (a 3.5% mid-strength) and Bondi Lager at $9, Coopers Australian Lager and Coopers Pale Ale at $12, Balter XPA, Guinness and Magners cider at $11, a Montauk IPA at $11, and Michelob Ultra at $8. The pub bills its beer as the coldest in New York.
Wine and cocktails. The list is almost entirely Australian, with a house red and white at $12 a glass and a $1,350 bottle of Penfolds Grange for anyone with something to celebrate. Cocktails are $15 and named for Aussie hits — Spinning Around, New Sensation, Walking on a Dream. The booze-free list has Heaps Normal beers at $9 and lemon, lime and bitters at $7.
Food. Pies are $15 (beef, or potato, leek and pea), the lamb sausage roll is $14, and any of them can be made to “float” for $8. Natural oysters are $24 a half dozen, Kilpatrick oysters $21 for three. The chicken parma is $29 with chips and salad (+$2 for pineapple, +$4 for ham), the Aussie burger with the lot — beetroot, pineapple, fried egg — is $25, fish and chips in Coopers sparkling-ale batter is $28, and dessert is pavlova ($14) or a Milo sundae ($16).
Trivia and roasts. Tuesday is trivia night, and it’s one of the few things Old Mates takes reservations for. The Sunday roast in the Harbour Room is seasonal: the pub’s menu, last updated in September 2026, says it’s off for the warmer months and coming back later in the year, so check before you plan a Sunday around it.
The Room
Old Mates calls itself “The Real Aussie Embassy.” It spreads over three floors, with room for a table of coworkers, a pool table in the back, a dance floor, and beer in real glassware. The pub takes inquiries for partial or full buyouts. Walk-ins are always welcome; reservations go through its online system only, for trivia and for lunch Monday to Friday and Sunday.
Go here instead: for an actual happy hour, The Paris Cafe, a few blocks up South Street at Peck Slip, does $2.50 oysters, $6 drafts, $9 house wine and $12 cocktails Wednesday to Saturday, 5–7pm. For more around here, see the South Street Seaport happy hour guide, the oyster happy hours in NYC and the best trivia nights in NYC.
Who Old Mates Pub Is For
| Occasion | Why It Works |
|---|---|
| Homesick Australians | Coopers, Bondi Lager, meat pies, parmas and pavlova |
| Tuesday trivia | Trivia night is bookable in advance |
| A big group from the office | Three floors, a pool table and a dance floor |
| A late one downtown | Open until 2am on Fridays and Saturdays |