The Black Whale, City Island: Since 1961, Open Wed–Sun
The Black Whale, at 279 City Island Ave, doesn’t post a happy hour. It’s a restaurant and bar that has been on the island since 1961, and it keeps a short week: Wednesday through Sunday from 4pm.
The verdict: a neighborhood dinner spot rather than a destination, and a calmer alternative to the big seafood halls at either end of the avenue. Sunday starts early with a brunch buffet, 10am to 2pm, with coffee and juice brought to the table. The catch: it posts no menu prices and no drink list, so there’s nothing to rank, and it’s closed Monday and Tuesday.
What to Expect
- Open: Wednesday to Sunday from 4pm
- Sunday brunch buffet: 10am–2pm, reservations recommended by the restaurant
See the full City Island happy hour guide. For more like it, see best brunch in NYC.