The Russian Tea Room, Midtown: Borscht, $25 Cocktails and Afternoon Tea
The Russian Tea Room is a Russian restaurant and tea room at 150 W 57th St in Midtown. It doesn’t post a happy hour; what it does have: an $85 three-course pre-theatre menu from 4:45 to 6:15pm, not for parties of eight or more. The verdict: the Carnegie Hall neighbor celebrating its 100th year, where nothing is cheap and the flat $25 cocktail is close to the bargain. No happy hour; the best-value way in is the $85 pre-theatre menu at 4:45pm, borscht to blintzes.
What to Expect
Dinner runs daily from 4 to 11pm and reads like a greatest-hits list: RTR borscht with a beef pirozhok ($28), pelmeni ($30), pirozhki ($29), beef stroganoff with truffle oil ($49), chicken Kiev ($49), salmon kulebyaka ($57) and a $65 beef Wellington. The classic afternoon tea is $145 a person, with caviar on blini, finger sandwiches, Russian chocolate salami, scones and a glass of champagne or prosecco.
The Drinks
Every cocktail on the list is $25: the RTR dirty martini with horseradish-infused Beluga vodka, the Cosmonaut, a Russian 75 with jasmine-tea vodka and prosecco, and a Moscow mule built on peach-tea vodka. The caviar martini, Stoli Elite served with 10 grams of Hackleback, is $40. For the centennial, champagne-and-caviar pairings start at $325 for Chavost brut nature with an ounce of Sevruga.
When to Go
Open 11:30am to 11pm on weekdays and from 11am on weekends. The pre-theatre menu runs 4:45 to 6:15pm, and the restaurant places itself slightly to the left of Carnegie Hall and six minutes and 23 seconds from Lincoln Center. Nearest trains are 57 St-7 Av (N/Q/R/W) and 57 St (M).
The Honest Caveat
No happy hour and no bar specials. Prices run high on everything: $28 borscht, $145 afternoon tea, $25 for any cocktail, and caviar pairings that climb to $1,275. The pre-theatre menu isn’t available to parties of eight or more, and the window is only 90 minutes long.
For a drink deal nearby, see our Midtown happy hour guide and where to eat in Midtown. For more like it: best afternoon tea in NYC, best restaurants near broadway.