Own a NYC bar or restaurant? Get listed free →
HAPPY HOUR NYCGet City Island deals

Bronx/City Island

Tony's Pier

Happy hour on nowStarts soonWaterfront seafood restaurantOysters & seafood$$
Directions

Own Tony's Pier? Claim this page free, or try Featured free for 30 days.

Happy hourNo happy hour
Best forFried seafood on the water · Piña coladas · Big groups
What to expect✓ Checked November 2026

No happy hour posted. A cash-only, cafeteria-style seafood house at the very end of City Island Avenue, with fried shrimp at $18 and a dozen steamed clams at $18.

Something changed? Tell us
What changed?

Go here instead

No happy hour at Tony's Pier. For a deal within a few blocks:

Man Overboard Bar On nowA cheap early round · Live bands · Sports on the TVs · Daily 3–6pmATIK Restaurant On nowWaterfront dinner · Oysters and a spritz · Weekend brunch · Mon–Fri 3–7pm

Free · one email a week

Like this? Get City Island’s best happy hours every Wednesday

  • Three deals worth leaving the house for, checked that week
  • What quietly got worse, so you skip it
  • No spam. Unsubscribe in one click

Join about 2,000 New Yorkers who get it.

Tony's Pier, City Island: Cash-Only Fried Seafood at the End of the Island

Tony’s Pier, at 1 City Island Ave where the island runs out, doesn’t post a happy hour. It’s a 276-seat, cash-only seafood restaurant with cafeteria-style seating indoors and out, and it says it’s open all year.

The verdict: you come for the platter and the water, and the prices are fair for both. Ten fried shrimp are $18, so are fried calamari and a dozen steamed clams, and a half dozen baked clams is $10. The bar is known for piña coladas. The catch: bring cash, and don’t expect table service.

What to Expect

  • Fried dinners: shrimp (10 pieces) $18, calamari $18, whiting $18, porgy $17, scallops $23
  • Steamed and baked: steamed clams (12) $18, baked clams (12) $20 or (6) $10
  • Broiled: salmon $34, red snapper $39, lobster tails at market price

Hours: daily 11:30am–11pm.

See the full City Island happy hour guide. For more like it, see best seafood restaurants in NYC.

More happy hours nearby

Other spots in City Island, and the full City Island happy hour guide.

Man Overboard Bar On nowDaily 3–6pmATIK Restaurant On nowMon–Fri 3–7pmVistamar Restaurant & Lounge On nowMon–Fri noon–7pmJohnny's Reef On nowCafeteria-style seafood restaurant

Tony's Pier: FAQ

Does Tony's Pier have a happy hour?

Not one that it posts. Expect regular prices.

Is Tony's Pier open in winter?

Yes. It says it's open all year, 11:30am to 11pm every day.

Does Tony's Pier take cards?

No. It describes itself as a cash-only restaurant.

What does it cost?

Fried shrimp (10 pieces) and fried calamari are $18, a dozen steamed clams $18, a dozen baked clams $20, broiled salmon $34 and red snapper $39.

Deal and times last checked November 2026. Details change. Spot something out of date? Tap “Something changed?” on this page.