Ann & Tony's, Arthur Avenue: Red Sauce Since 1927 & $10 Wine
Ann & Tony’s Restaurant is an Italian restaurant at 2407 Arthur Ave in Bronx. It doesn’t post a happy hour. The verdict: a family-run Arthur Avenue red-sauce room the same family has run at this address since 1927. No happy hour, but $10 red wine by the glass and $17 baked ziti keep the bill honest for the street.
What to Expect
The family history is the pitch: Eugenio Napolitano bought 2407 Arthur Avenue in 1927, and his great-grandson Anthony now cooks. The menu is pure Arthur Avenue. Fried calamari is $19, baked clams $13 and clams casino $14; baked ziti is $17, penne alla vodka $20, rigatoni with broccoli rabe and sausage $23 and linguine with clam sauce $24. Veal Columbo with prosciutto in brandy cream is $27, and a seafood combo for the table runs $45.
The Drinks
Red wine by the glass (Chianti, Pinot Noir, Cabernet, Montepulciano) is $10 and Prosecco is $11. The signature cocktails lean on the neighborhood: the Arthur Avenue Wise Guy (Grey Goose, amaretto, Tuaca, pineapple), Eugenio’s Revenge (Maker’s Mark, Grand Marnier) and the Mario Test, a tequila-Campari drink at $16. Beers include First Premium Lager from Lagundo, Radeberger Pilsner, Founders Porter, Delirium Tremens and La Trappe Quadrupel.
When to Go
Closed Monday. Open Tuesday to Thursday noon to 9pm, Friday and Saturday noon to 10pm, and Sunday noon to 8pm. Reservations are suggested but not required, and parties of six or more should book. It’s closed on Thanksgiving and Christmas Day, open Christmas Eve, New Year’s Eve and New Year’s Day. Gluten-free pasta is available.
The Honest Caveat
No happy hour and no drink specials posted, and plenty of entrees on the online menu carry no listed price, so budget by the ones that do. Monday is dark, and Sunday service ends at 8pm.
For a drink deal nearby, see our Bronx happy hour guide. For more like it: best Italian restaurants in NYC, best private dining rooms in NYC, best group dinner spots in NYC.