Ellen's Stardust Diner: Singing Servers, Broadway Prices
Ellen’s Stardust Diner is a Times Square diner with singing servers at 1650 Broadway in the Theater District. It doesn’t post a happy hour; what it does have: a ticketed MAMMA MIA! brunch in the Stardust Theatre downstairs, $50 with an entree and soft drinks or $75 with bottomless mimosas, plus tax and tip, on set show dates. The verdict: you come for the show, not the value. The servers sing from open to close, every day, and the bill is priced like a Broadway ticket: $21 cocktails, a $25.50 burger and a 20% tip already on the check. Bring the kids or the out-of-towners, skip it for a cheap drink.
What to Expect
Breakfast runs all day: Challah French toast ($18.95), buttermilk pancakes ($17.95), eggs Benedict ($21.95) and a corned beef hash called the Morning Glory ($23.95). Later it’s diner comfort at Midtown prices: the Big Bopper, an 8 oz burger with waffle fries ($25.50), the bacon-and-mushroom Be Bop a Lula ($29.75), rigatoni Bolognese ($33), turkey chili ($15) and Stardust nachos ($17.95). Dessert is the rainbow cake ($12.50) or the Kitchen Sink sundae, $45 and built for six.
The Drinks
It’s a full bar, not a soda fountain. House cocktails like Glinda’s Popular Potion (gin, St-Germain, prosecco) and martinis are $21 each, classics like a mimosa or Bloody Mary are $16, and frozen piña coladas and mudslides are $22. Wine is $16 a glass. The cheapest drinks on the list are the beers: Blue Moon on draft at $9, Stella and Mermaid IPA at $10, and Coors Light bottles at $8.
When to Go
Open every day from 7am to midnight, holidays included, and the singing waitstaff, the Stardusters, perform from open to close, so there’s no bad hour for the show. It doesn’t take reservations, and the diner says waits vary by season and day. Groups of 25 or more can book a private party. It’s at 1650 Broadway; nearest trains 50 St (1) and 7 Av (E/B/D).
The Honest Caveat
No happy hour and nothing cheap: cocktails are $21, wine is $16, and a 20% gratuity is added to every check as a convenience (the menu says they’ll take it off if you ask). No reservations means a wait at busy times, and the MAMMA MIA! brunch needs a ticket bought in advance.
For a drink deal nearby, see our Theater District happy hour guide. For more like it: best diners in NYC, best restaurants near broadway, best late-night food in NYC.