Sagaponack: $1.25 Oysters Until 6:30pm in the Flatiron
Sagaponack’s happy hour — the restaurant calls it the Hamptons Express — runs Monday to Saturday, 4 to 6:30pm, at 4 West 22nd Street in the Flatiron: $1.25 oysters and cocktail shrimp (12 max per guest), $4 shooters, $10 cocktails, $5 lager and $7 wine.
The verdict: an oyster happy hour worth planning around. The Peconic Bay oysters are $3 apiece on the regular raw bar menu, six minimum; from 4 to 6:30 they’re $1.25, less than half. Cocktails drop from $15–$16 to $10, and the bites take a real cut — Parmesan fries go from $11 to $7. Two catches: the 12-per-guest cap, and the calendar. The happy hour is billed as “daily” in one place and Monday to Saturday in another, and there are no Sunday hours posted, so don’t plan a Sunday around it.
The Happy Hour
Monday to Saturday, 4–6:30pm. Raw bar: East Coast oysters from Peconic Bay, $1.25 each, and cocktail shrimp, $7.50 for six. Bites: Parmesan fries $7, shishito peppers $7, miso hummus $8. Cocktails, $10 each: spicy margarita, lychee spritz, seasonal sangria. Wine, $7 a glass: Prosecco, Pinot Grigio, rosé, Cabernet Sauvignon. Lager $5. Shooters, $4: tequila with pineapple and yuzu, or Four Roses bourbon with Korean ginger-cinnamon tea. The Bloody MEILI — a gazpacho-dressed oyster with a shot of MEILI vodka — is $6.50.
The Room
Sagaponack is named after the first owner’s favorite Hamptons town and, by its own account, has been open more than a decade; the current team took over in October 2020. The menu is beach-house seafood with detours: a $34 chili lobster roll, a $24 Maine crab roll, branzino with Ghanaian-style greens, suya beef skewers with jollof rice. Doors open at 4pm, so the happy hour is the first two and a half hours of the day. The 23 St stations on the R/W and F/M are the closest trains. More nearby in our Flatiron happy hour guide, and more cheap shellfish in our oyster happy hour roundup.
Who Sagaponack Is For
| Occasion | Why It Works |
|---|---|
| Oysters after work | $1.25 East Coast oysters, Mon–Sat 4–6:30pm |
| A cheap first round | $4 shooters, $7 wine, $5 lager |
| Lobster roll dinner | $34 chili lobster roll on the dinner menu |