John Mulligan’s Fireside Pub: a Woodlawn Irish local since 1977
John Mulligan’s Fireside Pub is a family-owned Irish local that has anchored Woodlawn’s Katonah Avenue since 1977. It’s the real thing: a fireplace (hence the name), dark wood, a proper pint of Guinness, and a wall of regulars who’ve been coming for decades. This is the heart of the North Bronx Irish community, not a themed pub.
The kitchen is a genuine draw here — Fireside is known for burgers so good the crowd calls them the best in the Bronx, a reputation that got a boost when Law & Order: SVU filmed on-site. Beyond the food, expect Gaelic games and general sports on the screens, darts and pool in back, plus karaoke, open mic, and live bands on the calendar.
What to Expect
There’s no formally published happy hour at Fireside — like most Woodlawn and McLean Avenue pubs, the specials are run by the bartender based on the day, the crowd, and what’s on tap. Come for a well-poured Guinness and the burgers rather than a fixed drink deal, and ask what’s going on when you sit down.
The Room
A cozy, old-school Irish neighborhood pub with a fireplace, dark wood, and longtime regulars. There’s a livelier back with darts and pool tables plus a private party room, and the screens run Gaelic games and sports.
Who John Mulligan’s Fireside Pub Is For
| Occasion | Why It Works |
|---|---|
| Pints with the neighborhood | A genuine family-run local since 1977, ideal for a relaxed Guinness among regulars. |
| Watching GAA and sports | Screens run Gaelic games and general sports, making it a go-to for Irish football and hurling. |
| Burgers in the Bronx | The kitchen’s burgers have a citywide reputation, even earning an on-screen nod from an SVU shoot. |
| Late nights and live music | Open until about 4 AM with karaoke, open mic, and live bands keeping weekends going. |
More NYC Happy Hours
JP Clarke’s · Woodlawn
JP Clarke’s sits on the McLean Avenue strip in the Woodlawn ‘Little Ireland’ scene, just over the Bronx line in Yonkers.
Rambling House · Woodlawn
Rambling House is one of Woodlawn’s anchor Irish pubs, a big wraparound-bar spot on Katonah Avenue that pours a proper Guinness and packs…
City Island Lobster House · City Island
Bronx Waterfront Seafood
John Mulligan’s Fireside Pub FAQ
Is John Mulligan’s Fireside Pub in Manhattan?
No. John Mulligan’s Fireside Pub is in Woodlawn in the North Bronx, at 4272 Katonah Avenue. A separate, unrelated pub called Mulligan’s Pub sits in Murray Hill in Manhattan — they’re easy to confuse but not the same place.
Does Fireside Pub have a happy hour?
There’s no formally published happy hour with set days and prices. Like most Woodlawn pubs, specials are run informally by the bartender depending on the day and crowd, so it’s worth asking when you arrive.
What’s Fireside known for?
A proper pint of Guinness and its burgers, which locals rate among the best in the Bronx. It’s also a hub for Gaelic games, darts, pool, karaoke, and live music.
How do I get there by subway?
Take the 4 train to its northern terminus at Woodlawn, a few blocks from Katonah Avenue. Metro-North’s Harlem Line also stops at Woodlawn.
Happy hour times and deals last verified June 2026. Details can change — confirm with John Mulligan’s Fireside Pub before visiting for a specific deal.